Wednesday 3 February 2016

5. THE THREE TEACHINGS OF VIETNAM AS AN IDEOLOGICAL PRECONDITION FOR THE FOUNDATION OF CAODAISM


Image result for chùa xa loi

Xá Lợi pagoda in Saigon

III. AN OUTLINE OF VIETNAMESE BUDDHISM
1. BEFORE THE 3RD CENTURY
Under the rule of the Han aggressors, the area of present northern Vietnam was renamed Giao Chỉ Bộ. In 203, under the reign of Emperor Hiến Đế of the Han dynasty, Giao Chỉ Bộ was renamed Giao Châu.
At first Buddhism spread from India to Vietnam by sea when Indian trading vessels carried early Indian Buddhist monks to Giao Châu. Later, probably Luy Lâu (in Dâu area of Hà Bắc province) could be a gateway to China for Buddhist monks and long-journey traders.[1]
According to Thiền Uyển Truyền Đăng Tập Lục (A Record of the Lamp Transmission in the Zen Community), Dharma Master Đàm Thiên told a king of the Sui dynasty (581-618) that Giao Châu had a waterway to India. Thus, while Buddhism was still unknown in the area of Jiangdong (China), there were more than twenty Buddhist temples and over five hundred Buddhist monks in Luy Lâu citadel of Giao Châu, and fifteen Buddhist sūtras were well known there.[2]
An author asserts that Buddhism had spread from Vietnam to China before it was brought back from China to Vietnam. In the 3rd century, Sun Quan of the Wu kingdom in Jiangdong received Buddhist teachings from monk Khương Tăng Hội (?-280) coming from Giao Châu. Then Sun Quan had Jianchu Temple built.[3]
Đại Việt Sử Ký Toàn Thư (Complete History of Great Việt) and Wuzhi (Records of the Wu Kingdom, written in the 4th century) recorded a letter from a Chinese mandarin named Yuan Hui to Shangshu Ling (Director of the Imperial Secretariat) Xun Yu in 207, saying that whenever Taishou (Prefect) Shi Xie (137-226) of Giao Châu went out, he was accompanied by several Indian monks burning incense, playing bells, drums and flutes.[4]
Because the North (i.e., Giao Châu formerly) was early in direct contact with Buddhism, the northern Vietnamese have the term Bụt (transliterated from Buddha). After contacting Chinese Buddhism, the Vietnamese have the term Phật, borrowed the Chinese transliteration of Buddha (Futuo, or Phật Đà in Sino-Vietnamese). Afterwards, the direct spread of Buddhism from India to Vietnam gradually declined whereas its spread from China to Vietnam by land increased.
Influenced by Chinese Buddhist tradition coming from the north, Vietnamese Buddhism belongs to mahāyāna, also called Bắc Tông (Northern School). Under the influence of Southern Buddhist tradition (like Buddhism in neighbouring countries such as Laos, Cambodia, Thailand), Vietnamese Buddhism belongs to hīnayāna, also called Nam Tông (Southern School) or Nguyên Thủy (Theravāda). It should be noticeable that both terms mahāyāna and hīnayāna do not imply that which one is better than the other.
2. FROM THE 3RD CENTURY TO THE FIRST HALF OF THE 13TH CENTURY
Of several Buddhist schools in Vietnam, Chanzong (Zen School) had the strongest growth and bore many distinctive features.
At the beginning of the 3rd century, monk Khương Tăng Hội founded Zen Buddhism of Vietnam and was the first monk to bring Buddhism from Vietnam to China.
At that time, according to an author, Vietnamese Buddhism belongs to mahāyāna because monk Khương Tăng Hội and some eminent monks translated Prajñāpāramitā Sūtra; monk Kalasivi translated Lotus Samādhi Sūtra.[5]
Documents on Vietnamese Buddhism in the 4th century are not extant.
Tục Cao Tăng Truyện (Continuation of the Biographies of Eminent Monks) says in the 5th century Zen Master Huệ Thắng, a disciple of monk Đạt-ma Đề-bà (Dharmadeva?), went to China many times to spread Buddhism.[6]
From the 6th century to the end of the Lý dynasty (1225), there were three major Zen schools in Vietnam:
- The Vinītaruci School: In 580 Zen Master Vinītaruci arrived in Việt Nam, settled down at Pháp Vân Temple in Bắc Ninh province for fourteen years, and passed away in 594. This school had nineteen generations, and Zen Master Y Sơn (?-1213) belonged to the last one.
- The Wu Yan Tong School: In 820 Zen Master Wu Yan Tong (759?-826) left China for Vietnam and dwelt at Kiến Sơ Temple in Bắc Ninh province. This school lasted seventeen generations, and King Lý Thái Tông (reigned 1028-1054) belonged to the eighth one.
- The Caotang School: Zen Master Caotang left China and came to Champa. In a successful expedition against Champa (1069), King Lý Thánh Tông took the monk to Thăng Long imperial city and made him Quốc Sư (National Preceptor). The monk dwelt at Khai Quốc Temple. The Caotang School lasted six generations. Nine noteworthy disciples of this school were King Lý Thánh Tông (reigned 1054-1072) of the second generation, Tham Chính (Grand Councilor) Ngô Ích of the third generation, King Lý Anh Tông (reigned 1138-1175) and Thái Phó (Grand Mentor) Đỗ Vũ of the fourth generation, Thái Phó Đỗ Thường of the fifth generation, King Lý Cao Tông (reigned 1175-1210) and Quản Giáp (Supervisor) Nguyễn Thức of the sixth generation.
3. VIETNAMESE BUDDHISM UNDER THE TRẦN DYNASTY
At the beginning of the 13th century, the Vinītaruci, the Wu Yan Tong, and the Caotang Schools gradually merged into the Yên Tử School, and finally became the only school of Trúc Lâm Yên Tử under the Trần dynasty.
The Yên Tử School arose on mount Yên Tử (Thượng Yên Công village, Uông Bí town, Quảng Ninh province today).
Its founder patriarch was Zen Master Hiện Quang (?-1221).
Zen Master Đạo Viên (also called Viên Chứng), whose disciple was King Trần Thái Tông (reigned 1226-1258), was the second patriarch. The King conferred the title Trúc Lâm Quốc Sư (Bamboo Grove National Preceptor) on his Master.
The sixth patriarch was vua Trần Nhân Tông (reigned 1278-1293). He became a monk at Hoa Yên pagoda on mount Yên Tử (1299). His Dharma name was Hương Vân Ðầu Ðà, then changed to Trúc Lâm Ðầu Ðà (Bamboo Grove Dhūta).[7]
The Yên Tử School had flourished since its sixth patriarch (Trúc Lâm Ðầu Ðà, i.e., King Trần Nhân Tông). The name Trúc Lâm Yên Tử School (or Trúc Lâm School for short) began thenceforth, and the King was the founder.
Zen Master Tĩnh Lự (also called Phù Vân) was the fifth patriarch of the Trúc Lâm Yên Tử School, i.e., the tenth of the Yên Tử School. Caodai holy teaching once referred to Phù Vân Quốc Sư (National Preceptor) under the Trần dynasty; maybe that was him.
In the royal family there was an eminent zen master called Tuệ Trung Thượng Sĩ (1230-1291), whose lay name was Trần Quốc Trung, titled Hưng Ninh Vương (Improved Tranquilness Prince). As the eldest son of An Sinh Vương (Welfare Prince) Trần Liễu, he was the eldest brother of Hưng Đạo Vương (Improved Way Prince) Trần Quốc Tuấn.
King Trần Thái Tông’s Khóa Hư Lục (Instructions on Emptiness) and Tuệ Trung Thượng Sĩ’s Ngữ Lục (Recorded Sayings) are the two masterpieces of Zen literature under the Trần dynasty.
4. FROM THE 15TH CENTURY TO THE 19TH CENTURY
The collapses of the two successive dynasties of Hồ (1400-1407) and Later Trần (1407-1413) were followed by the Chinese Ming army’s aggression. Due to continuous war and disorder, Buddhism declined. After defeating the Chinese invaders, King Lê Thái Tổ (reigned 1428-1433) organized exams to assess the competence of Buddhist monks and Daoist priests. He who failed had to return to secular life.[8]
When the Hậu Lê dynasty declined, the Trịnh Lords ruled in the North and the Nguyễn Lords controlled the South. Buddhism weakened. At the beginning of the 18th century, after uniting the nation, Emperor Quang Trung (reigned 1788-1792) restored Buddhism positively, reorgannized the establishment of pagodas, imposed regulations on constructing large and well-organized temples, dismissed unqualified monks and forced them to return to secular life.[9]
From the 15th century on, Vietnamese Buddhism no longer flourished like that of the Lý and Trần dynasties, but eminent monks always appeared under any dynasty. Some Zen schools were known during this period. In the North there were the Chinese Caodong (Tào Động) under King Lê Thế Tông (reigned 1573-1599) and the Liên Tông (the Lotus School) under King Lê Hy Tông (reigned 1676-1705). In central Vietnam, the Liễu Quán and the Nguyên Thiều arose. With its Chinese origin as a branch of the Lâm Tế lineage, the Nguyên Thiều school was founded under King Lê Huyền Tông (reigned 1663-1671).
On 01 September 1858, the first cannon shot of French navy attacking Đà Nẵng estuary started a century-long aggression of the French colonialism. Due to continuous war and disorder, Buddhism gradually declined.
*
At the beginning of the 20th century the movement of restoring Buddhism arose in many areas of Vietnam. Eminent monks after their long seclusion now started spreading Buddhism. Thanks to improved printing means, Buddhological books and magazines could be distributed more widely.
Besides eminent monks, there were also intellectual lay Buddhists of both traditional and western learning who mastered secular knowledge as well as Buddhology. Throughout the three regions of the country, talented and enthusiastic lay Buddhists contributed positively to the reform of traditional preaching method. Among the well-known figures were Nguyễn Hữu Kha, Lê Đình Thám, and Mai Thọ Truyền.
a. Thiều Chửu Nguyễn Hữu Kha (1902-1954): A traditional physician; founder of Hội Phật Học Bắc Kỳ (the Society of Buddhology in Northern Vietnam), based at Quán Sứ pagoda in Hà Nội. He was in charge of Đuốc Tuệ (Prajña Torch) magazine of his society.
b. Tâm Minh Lê Đình Thám (1887-1969): A medical doctor; founder and head of Hội Phật Học Trung Kỳ (the Society of Buddhology in Central Vietnam) also called An Nam Phật Học Hội (the Society of Buddhology of Annam), based at Trúc Lâm (Bamboo Grove) pagoda in Huế. He was director and editor-in-chief of Viên Âm (Enlightenment Voice) monthly magazine of his society.
c. Chánh Trí Mai Thọ Truyền (1905-1973): Đốc Phủ Sứ (a high-ranking colonial civil officer), founder of both Xá Lợi (Śarīra) pagoda (District 3, Sài Gòn) and Hội Phật Học Nam Việt (the Society of Buddhology in Southern Vietnam). He was a devoted contributor to Từ Quang (Merciful Light) magazine of his society.

Later, the systematic training of Vietnamese monks and nuns at elementary, intermediate, and advanced levels, as well as college degree resulting from the fervent movement of restoring Buddhism emerged during some first decades of the 20th century as Caodaism arose. For Caodaists, according to a spiritual message, this concurrence was not a coincidence.

Indeed, at Bác Nhã Zen Monastery (Long Hải, Vũng Tàu, on 02 July 1974), Caodai God taught:

“In respect of Dao, you do know that My third advent is to revive all mankind on earth in My salvation grace permeating throughout the five continents. Fifty or sixty years ago, as you see, all religions seemed to be in a heavy sleep. However, since the wide spread of Caodaism, other religions have been successively restored. Such resurrection has come not only to you but to all mankind. Therefore, moral movements have been revived everywhere.”
HUỆ KHẢI





[1] [Nguyễn Lang 1974: 25].
[2] [Nguyễn Lang 1974: 32] và [Trần Văn Giáp 1968: 46].
[3] [Nguyễn Lang 1974: 28, 33, 34] và [Trần Văn Giáp 1968: 53].
[4] [Nguyễn Lang 1974: 30]; [Trần Văn Giáp 1968: 41] và [Ngô Sĩ Liên 1974: 243].
[5] [Nguyễn Lang 1974: 73, 75].
[6] [Nguyễn Lang 1974: 87, 88].
[7] Dhūta means to get rid of the trials of life and attain nirvāna.
[8] [Trần Trọng Kim 1971b: 247].
[9] [Trần Trọng Kim 1971c: 142].