Sunday 17 March 2024

POPE NGUYỄN NGỌC TƯƠNG'S CHRONOLOGICAL BIOGRAPHY (part two)

 POPE NGUYỄN NGỌC TƯƠNG'CHRONOLOGICAL BIOGRAPHY

(Continued)

By Huệ Khải

SATURDAY, 05 JANUARY 1935

TO WEDNESDAY, 06 FEBRUARY 1935

Apostle Nguyễn Ngọc Tương engaged in intensive meditation, and completely abstained from food. He prayed for blessings bestowed on sentient beings at the beginning of the new year.

MONDAY, 11 FEBRUARY 1935

TO THURSDAY 14 FEBRUARY 1935

At 8 a.m., the All Spirits Assembly opened at An Hội holy house, with eighty-eight parishes from twenty provinces attending. As chairman, Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang explained:

“It is called the All Spirits Assembly because it comprises all Caodaists, from high-ranking Divinely-appointed dignitaries to believers. As the greatest assembly in Caodaism, it includes all three of these: the Humans Assembly, the Holy Assembly, and the Supreme Assembly (Thượng Hội 上會).

The power of the All Spirits Assembly naturally must be greater than that of others in Caodaism. According to holy messages, the power of all spirits is equivalent to that of the Supreme Being. Therefore, the decisions made by all spirits signify the decisions of the Supreme Being. It is said that the people’s will represents the Heaven’s will.

The All Spirits Assembly is responsible for deciding the most important issues of Caodaism, which other assemblies cannot decide, such as electing the dignitary to lead Caodaism.

Why is the All Spirits Assembly convened today?

After the passing of our Eldest Brother, Mr. Thượng Trung Nhựt, the Nonuple Hierarchy (Cửu Trùng Đài 九重臺) lacks the representative of our Master to hold the power of Caodaism on earth. Whenever there is a vacancy, it is naturally to be filled, rather than left vacant, because if there is no head, how can the body function?

 Currently, within the Holy Assembly, the high-ranking Divinely-appointed dignitaries who hold the positions next to our Eldest Brother are these three Acting Cardinals: Thượng Tương Thanh, Ngọc Trang Thanh, and Thái Thơ Thanh, respectively in accordance with their heavenly appointments.

Since the beginning of Caodaism, numerous holy messages from the Supreme Being and Spiritual Pope Lý Thái Bạch have foretold that Mr. Thượng Tương Thanh will lead Caodaism.([1])

(...)

Due to Mr. Thượng Tương Thanh’s current position in the Holy Assembly and according to the holy messages from the Supreme Being and Pope Lý Thái Bạch, I would like to request the Holy Assembly to elect Mr. Thượng Tương Thanh to lead Caodaism in order to comply with the Heaven's will and the Caodai Law. However, Mr. Thượng Tương Thanh has insistently declined, as Caodaism has already split into many branches. Furthermore, the holy messages from the Supreme Being and Pope Lý Thái Bạch were bestowed a long time ago, and it is not known if followers still have full faith in them.

In addition, after the burial of our Eldest Brother, Mr. Dharma Protector took over the Pope's power and issued the Decree dated 12 December 1934, which was signed as follows: 'In charge of the two visible corps: the Heaven Uniting and the Nonuple Hierarchies: Dharma Protector Phạm Công Tắc'. This action goes against the law: the Heaven Uniting Hierarchy is responsible for the spiritual part, which is the soul; the Nonuple Hierarchy is responsible for the material part, which is the body. These two corps have special powers, and neither corps can encroach upon the other. If the Heaven Uniting Hierarchy dignitaries cross over to the Nonuple Hierarchy, then the Heaven Uniting Hierarchy must be left empty, meaning that when the soul dissipates, the body must disintegrate.

Due to the aforementioned reasons, this issue is highly critical to Caodaism. Performing their duties, consequently, the two Acting Cardinals convened both the Caodaism Rectifying Board and the Holy Assembly to discuss this crucial issue. However, as these two conventions could not reach a resolution, the All Spirits Assembly has been called for today.

(...)

Why is the All Spirits Assembly convened at An Hội holy house in Bến Tre province rather than the Tây Ninh Holy See?

This is due to the Tây Ninh Holy See’s dignitaries. Mr. Thượng Tương Thanh wrote a letter dated 15 January 1935, requesting Dharma Protector Phạm Công Tắc’s approval for the All Spirits Assembly to be convened at the Holy See (...). However, Mr. Dharma Protector responded unfavourably; hence, the Assembly is convened here today.

After its vote for the leader of Caodaism and subsequent discussion, the Assembly will decide to return to the Holy See; thus, it is not too late.

I would like to remind brethren that Mr. Thượng Tương Thanh still holds the Tây Ninh holy land in trust for Caodaism. No one has the right to prevent believers and him from returning to the Holy See.([2])

The Thượng Legist-Censor presided over the voting session, which began at 2:30 p.m. on 11 February and concluded at 6 p.m. on 13 February.

TUESDAY, 12 FEBRUARY 1935

The All Spirits Assembly at An Hội holy house wrote up the minutes of the Tây Ninh Holy See’s claim to the holy land and holy houses (excerpt):

“Mr. Dharma Protector and Mrs. Principal Archbishop sent a letter to Mr. Thượng Tương Thanh claiming the land of the Holy See and holy houses registered under his name.

After careful consideration, the All Spirits Assembly unanimously decided to entrust the entire property of Caodaism to the elected leader of the religion (...).” ([3])

THURSDAY, 14 FEBRUARY 1935

At 8 a.m., the All Spirits Assembly gathered around a thousand attendees. The Management Team (Ban Trị Sự 治 事班) checked the ballot box and found five thousand three hundred and fifty-three votes,([4]) of which: Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang received twenty-seven votes; Thượng Cardinal Nguyễn Ngọc Tương received five thousand three hundred and twenty-six votes. (There were five thousand three hundred and twenty-five votes requesting to return to the Tây Ninh Holy See.)

In the afternoon, the All Spirits Assembly reconvened from 3:00 to 6:30 p.m., with around a thousand attendees. Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang announced the ballot count report. The All Spirits Assembly rose together to welcome Thượng Cardinal Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, who had been elected to the leading position in Caodaism. Mr. Thượng Tương Thanh delivered the following speech:

Dear brethren,

When convening the All Spirits Assembly, realising my lack of ability and virtue, I declared that I will not stand for candidacy. But you all trust me and voted for me overwhelmingly, which deeply moved me. I would like to express my appreciation and thanks to all brethren present here and absent.

Moreover, the duty of leading Caodaism is very weighty. If uncertain whether Heaven’s power assists, no one would dare receive it. The trust of all brethren has been clearly shown today. I firmly believe that it is Heaven's mandate. Therefore, I dare not refuse and must bow my head in obedience.

Since you have all trusted me and entrusted me with these burdens, from now on, I do ask for your help in fulfilling my duties. Regarding the matter of whether or not to return to the Tây Ninh Holy See, everyone has almost unanimously voted in favour. I also cherish this aspiration. However, considering possible obstacles, we must figure out how to return there in peace and harmony.

I think that we should request our Thượng Legist-Censor and the All Spirits Assembly to resolve this difficult matter.([5])

Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang declared: 1/ Mr. Cardinal Thượng Tương Thanh has accepted the position he won in the election today. 2/ He has also agreed to return to the Tây Ninh Holy See. 3/ Regarding his coronation ceremony, I intend to hold it at the Tây Ninh Holy See with the participation of Caodai branches. Do you all agree with me?" Everyone agreed.

The All Spirits Assembly elected Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang, Thượng Sanh 上生 Cao Hoài Sang (1901-1971), and Dharma Conservator Nguyễn Trung Hậu to go to the Tây Ninh Holy See to negotiate reconciliation.([6])

TUESDAY, 19 FEBRUARY 1935

TO SATURDAY, 23 FEBRUARY 1935

According to the All Spirits Assembly’s resolution on Thursday, 14 February 1935, Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang, Thượng Sanh Cao Hoài Sang, and Dharma Conservator Nguyễn Trung Hậu led a large delegation to the Tây Ninh Holy See to negotiate the unification.

Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang sent a letter to Dharma Protector Phạm Công Tắc and members of the Assistance Team (Ban Phụ Chánh 輔政班), but the delegation was not received.

On 21 February 1935, Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang sent his second letter to Dharma Protector Phạm Công Tắc, stating that by 12 a.m. Saturday, 23 February 1935, his negotiation duty would be concluded.

On Saturday, 23 February, at 10 a.m., Dharma Protector Phạm Công Tắc sent Dao Receiver (Tiếp Đạo 接道) Cao Đức Trọng (1897-1958), a member of the Assistance Team, to meet privately with Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang. The Dao Receiver explained that the delegation consisting of seven or eight hundred individuals arrived without prior notice; so, it was inconvenient to receive them all at the Holy See. Nevertheless, receiving only the Thượng Legist-Censor implied receiving the whole delegation. The Thượng Legist-Censor had full authority to decide the issue of returning to the Tây Ninh Holy See; however, the Assistance Team should be informed five days in advance for preparation.([7])

THURSDAY, 04 APRIL 1935

The Bến Tre Holy Assembly sent invitations to dignitaries (including Student-Priests and above) to attend the coronation ceremony of Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương at An Hội holy house in Bến Tre province.

THURSDAY, 11 APRIL 1935

In Bến Tre province, Thượng Cardinal Nguyễn Ngọc Tương sent Circular to dignitaries, officials, and followers of both genders (excerpts):

  “Since 14 January until now, for almost two months, His Excellency Thượng Legist-Censor has been performing the command of the All Spirits Assembly, dedicating himself to negotiating with the Tây Ninh Holy See, but his efforts are still not fruitful.

Consequently, His Excellency Thượng Legist-Censor and I have decided to establish an office at An Hội holy house in Bến Tre province to handle all Caodaism affairs. Upon receiving the command from our Great Merciful Father, we shall then return to the Tây Ninh Holy See.” ([8])

TUESDAY, 07 MAY 1935

An evocation séance was held at An Hội holy house, witnessed by Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang and Thượng Cardinal Nguyễn Ngọc Tương. The mediums were Châu and Lê Tam Tỉnh (1893-1966). His Holiness Lý Thái Bạch descended, instructing Thượng Legist-Censor on the coronation rituals.

WEDNESDAY, 08 MAY 1935

The negotiation with the Tây Ninh Holy See failed. As suggested by Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang and unanimously agreed upon, the coronation ceremony of Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương would be held at An Hội holy house.

According to the invitation dated Thursday 04 April 1935, dignitaries (including Student-Priests and above) attended An Hội holy house to participate in the coronation ceremony of Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương. At 5 p.m., amongst the attendees were: Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang; Thượng Cardinal Nguyễn Ngọc Tương; Bishops (five males, one female); Priests (twenty males, three females); Student-Priests (a hundred and seventy males; a hundred and eight females).([9])

THURSDAY, 09 MAY 1935

The coronation ceremony of Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương was celebrated with solemnity at noon. In the afternoon, the Bến Tre Holy Assembly reconvened at 4:30 p.m.

FRIDAY, 10 MAY 1935

The Bến Tre Holy Assembly approved Nội Luật Thánh Thất (The Holy House’s Internal Law) and allowed its promulgation ([10]) to provide guidance on how to organise the internal management of each parish.

SATURDAY, 11 MAY 1935

Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang made an announcement informing followers that, as of 09 May 1935, he had returned the authority to the Pope. In his announcement, the Thượng Legist-Censor quoted the sixteen-verse Prayer of Congratulations (Kinh Chúc Mừng) bestowed upon Nguyễn Ngọc Tương by Spiritual Pope Lý Thái Bạch on Wednesday midnight, 17 April 1935.

To the Grace of Merciful Father, we bow down.

Thy blessings nourish sentient beings.

Thee have fruitfully spread the Dao,

And sent a Saint to save all now.

Holding the Dao’s laws and regulations,

The Saint relieves suffering humans.

Everywhere people can live and work in peace,

Rejoicing to see the path of holiness.

Just and upright amidst all things,

He guides humans to evade the sea of delusion.

The world’s full of hardship and suffering,

Led by his torch, we can return to Heaven.

How happy when the Dao brightens,

And good clouds cover earth and heaven.

Relying on God’s eternal miracles,

How joyous when human sins are forgiven.([11])

MONDAY, 05 AUGUST 1935

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương started his intensive meditation for a hundred days at the Heavenly Principles Secret Transmission, ablove the Heavenly Bestowal Hall (Thiên Phong Đường 天封堂). In the last seven days, he completely abstained from food, except for a few sips of water each day.

1936

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương established the upper vehicle monastery, then the middle vehicle convent.

FRIDAY, 31 JANUARY 1936

The Bến Tre Holy Assembly held its first convention at An Hội holy house in Bến Tre province.([12]) At that time, the Holy Assembly had ninety-six holy houses, while Caodaism as a whole had a total of one hundred and thirty-five holy houses.

SUNDAY, CHỦ NHẬT 12 APRIL 1936

An Hội holy house in Bến Tre province published Châu Tri Chỉnh Đạo 1934-1936, consisting of 74 pages (16x24cm), printed at Bùi Văn Nhẫn printing house in Bến Tre province.([13]) Excluding Circulars No. 1 and No. 2, the publication consists of ten circulars as follows: No. 3 (dated 24 July 1934); No. 4 (dated 27 July 1934); No. 5 (dated 26 September 1934); số 6 (dated 20 November 1934); No. 7 (dated 05 December 1934); No. 8 (dated 15 December 1934); No. 9 (dated 29 December 1934); No. 10 (dated 15 January 1935). Along with other documents, it concludes with the minutes of the annual convention of the Bến Tre Holy Assembly at An Hội holy house held at 9 a.m. on Friday, 31 January 1936.

SATURDAY, 13 JUNE 1936

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương started his intensive meditation at the Heavenly Principles Secret Transmission above the Heavenly Bestowal Hall. Besides very little cooked rice, he still had fruits, coconut water, soya milk, and a little bit of rice porridge.

FRIDAY, 17 JULY 1936

After more than half a month of serious illness, Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang passed away at An Hội holy house. Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương had the announcement of his passing sent widely, including:

The telegram sent to Dharma Protector Phạm Công Tắc read: Avons douleur pour faire part décès notre grand frère Lê Bá Trang, survenu 17 Juillet, enterrement 21 Juillet.” (Translation: We are deeply saddened to inform you that our beloved elder, Lê Bá Trang, passed away on 17 July, to be burried on 21 July.)

The telegram sent to Mrs. Principal Archbishop Hương Thanh read: Avons douleur vous informer décès Chưởng Pháp Lê Bá Trang, survenu aujourd’hui à BenTre et demandons permission d’enterrer dans propriété commune derrière Grand Temple Tây Ninh. Attendons réponse demain.” (Translation: We are deeply saddened to inform you that Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang has just passed away today in Bến Tre. Expecting his burial behind the Holy See’s main temple. We await your response tomorrow.)([14])

SUNDAY, 19 JULY 1936

In the afternoon, Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương received two telegrams, accepting the burial of Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang behind the Holy See’s main temple.

The telegram from Dharma Protector Phạm Công Tắc read: “Au nom sacerdoce et au mien vous adresse condoléances émues. Autorise enterrer au Saint Siège.” (Translation: On behalf of the Holy Assembly and myself, I express my deepest condolences. Permission has been granted for burial at the Holy See.)

The telegram from Mrs. Principal Archbishop Hương Thanh read: Condoléances très émues, accord pour inhumation derrière Grand Temple.” (Translation: Please accept our deepest condolences. Agreement has been reached for burial behind the Main Temple.)([15])

TUESDAY, 21 JULY 1936

After three days of mourning at An Hội holy house, in the morning, Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, along with two dignitaries of the Heaven Uniting Hierarchy (Hiệp Thiên Đài 協天 臺) and followers, moved the coffin of Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang to the Tây Ninh Holy See.

In the afternoon, the mourning ceremony could not be held in the main temple, because the Tây Ninh Holy See requested that, when entering the main temple, everyone should wear mourning attire, not dignitary robes.([16])

Around 10 p.m., they reached a solution: The Thượng Legist-Censor’s coffin was positioned at “Nhà Giảng” (literally, lecture hall), and the ceremony would be held there the next day. The delegation from Bến Tre province spent the night at “Học Xá” (literally, house for learning).

THURSDAY, 23 JULY 1936

At 8 a.m., under the ceremonial guidance of Dharma Protector Phạm Công Tắc, the coffin of Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang was transferred to the burial site behind the main temple.

In the afternoon, Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương led the delegation to the Dharma Protector Hall (Hộ Pháp Đường 護法 堂) to say goodbye to Dharma Protector Phạm Công Tắc. The delegation returned to Bến Tre province within that day.

After the passing of Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang, Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương prohibited holding all evocation séances. Since then, the Bến Tre Holy Assembly has primarily relied on An Anthology of Holy Sayings (Thánh Ngôn Hiệp Tuyển), The New Law (Tân Luật), and The Orthodox Dharma (Pháp Chánh Truyền) for their practices. (Especially for The Orthodox Dharma, the Tây Ninh Holy See’s commentary is not accepted.) To handle every Caodaism affair, the Bến Tre Holy Assembly collectively discussed matters during monthly meetings, annual conventions, or exceptional ones.([17])

1937

Expecting to spread Caodaism beyond Cochinchina, Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương visited Huế and Hà Nội to survey the local conditions while Caodaism was under persecution due to the policy of the Royal Court in Huế.([18]) Accompanying him was his young male attendant,([19]) named Tô Văn Pho (1919-1998), who would play a highly essential role at Hà Nội holy house.([20])

SUNDAY, 16 MAY 1937

The inauguration of An Hội holy house was held. Amongst the attendees were: Nguyễn Bửu Tài and Nguyễn Thế Hiển (from the Tiên Thiên Holy Assembly); Phan Văn Thiệu (from the Minh Chơn Đạo Holy Assembly), etc.

THURSDAY, 08 JULY 1937

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương engaged in intensive meditation at the Heaven Uniting Sanctuary (Hiệp Thiên Đài). The entries in his meditation diary were detailed.([21])

SUNDAY, 08 AUGUST 1937

Nguyễn Ngọc Tương’s spouse, Mrs. Bùi Thị Giàu (born in 1884), passed away.

1938

Throughout the year, Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương visited holy houses, granted great amnesties and deliverance from suffering for all. The Pope explained:

Every human is subjected to numerous karmic obstacles which hinder their self-cultivation. Those who have been granted great amnesties are exempted from their past karmic sins, which facilitates their path to success in self-cultivation.

In addition to their past karmic sins, each human also experiences worldly sufferings due to their passionate accumulation, which hinders their liberation. By means of deliverance from suffering, Heavenly Powers bestow their “divine energy (điển lành) which helps believers who have strong faith rely on suffering deliverance to save themselves from worldly sufferings gradually and independently.

During the years 1938 and 1939, with the aim of spreading Caodaism, the Pope dispatched numerous dignitaries to central and northern Vietnam, also known as Annam and Tonkin. In Annam, twenty-five holy houses were founded, gathering around five thousand followers. In Tonkin, a holy house was established in Hanoi.([22])

SATURDAY, 15 JANUARY 1938

The organising team finalised the programme for the Thành Đạoceremony, which lasted from Monday, 07 February, to Monday, 14 February 1938. Subsequently, this programme was reviewed by Acting Principal Archbishops Thái Cậy Thanh and Thượng Lai Thanh, along with Bishop Ngọc Diêu Thanh.

MONDAY, 07 FEBRUARY 1938

TO MONDAY, 14 FEBRUARY 1938

Solemnly held at An Hội holy house, the Thành Đạo” ceremony was defined as follows: “This great event signifies the conclusion of the duty to rectify Caodaism and the mission fulfilment of Caodaist branches. From now on, there is only the Holy Assembly of the Great Way of the Third Universalism to guide sentient beings through the right path of self-cultivation in keeping with the orthodox teachings and the New Dharma bestowed by the Supreme Being. ([23])

1939

Since this year onwards, through writing, Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương repeatedly advised followers that at every designated time for worship, they should wholeheartedly pray for all sentient beings to swiftly evade their karmic retribution of mutual devastation. They should also recite the Sutra of Repentance (Kinh Sám Hối) as well as the Sutra of Deliverance (Kinh Cứu Khổ) as frequently as possible. He always reminded followers to diligently cultivate themselves and pray, rather than becoming involved in politics.

SUNDAY, 19 FEBRUARY 1939

TO FRIDAY, 17 MARCH 1939

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương engaged in intensive meditation for nearly a month.([24])

SATURDAY, 01 JULY 1939

TO FRIDAY, 07 JULY 1939

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương engaged in intensive meditation for a week. On the first day, he completely abstained from food. On the fifth day, he meditated through the day and night without sleep. On the last day, he gained more understanding of the Dao.([25])

THE END OF 1939

The Heavenly Principles Secret Transmission was relocated to plot where the Meditation House was built in Trước Hoa Kỳ Thọ” garden.([26])

WEDNESDAY, 24 JANUARY 1940

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương issued Circular No. 395 to send his new year greetings to followers.([27])

FRIDAY, 02 FEBRUARY 1940

TO SATURDAY, 04 MAY 1940

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương engaged in intensive meditation. On some days, he meditated from midnight until early evening (5-7 p.m.).

THURSDAY, 15 FEBRUARY 1940

Inauguration of the Meditation House.

TUESDAY, 14 MAY 1940

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương initiated the first mediation course at the Meditation House, following its inauguration on 15 February 1940. He personally taught meditation techniques.

FRIDAY, 15 NOVEMBER 1940

TO FRIDAY, 20 DECEMBER 1940

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương engaged in intensive meditation, consuming only one meal a day. On some days, he abstained from food altogether.

1941:

The middle-vehicle convent was relocated to a large lot of land (today in Bình Thắng hamlet, ward 6, Bến Tre city). Formerly, it was temporarily constructed near the kitchen of An Hội holy house.

WEDNESDAY, 22 JANUARY 1941

Because of the fault of two officials (chức việc) from Hiệp Thạnh parish in Tây Ninh province, and due to being framed of political involvement, apostle Nguyễn Ngọc Tương was sentenced to fifteen months in prison by the court.

After appealing against the verdict, he was retried on Tuesday, 08 April 1941, and sentenced to six months of suspended imprisonment.

THURSDAY, 10 APRIL 1941

Referring to his attendance in court twice (on 22 January and 08 April 1941), Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương issued Circular No. 418, in which he expressed, I am neither sad nor troubled by those who falsely accused me. I firmly believe that our Master knows everything. ([28])

1942:

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương sent several Teams for Clarifying the Dao (Ban Minh Đạo 明道班) to holy houses. He explained:

Minh means clarification. Đo means the performance of each dignitary and the faithfulness to Caodaism of each follower.

Conducting Minh Đo means going to places which still have shortcomings to ignite the torch of wisdom, illuminate the path of self-cultivation, clarify the duties of each dignitary, teach followers the law of Caodaism as well as methods of self-cultivation, and strengthen the faith within the parish, making it more steadfast...” ([29])

THURSDAY, 01 JANUARY 1942

TO SATURDAY, 07 FEBRUARY 1942

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương engaged in intensive meditation.([30])

AT MIDNIGHT ON MONDAY, 06 AND

INTO THE SMALL HOURS OF TUESDAY, 07 APRIL 1942

About a week ago, Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương worked and received dignitaries tirelessly day and night. He visited monasteries and other institutions. Every evening he worked until midnight. There were always two secretaries by his side to assist him with paperwork.

Before engaging in his intensive meditation, he was working and chating, sharing the joys and sorrows in his lifetime of performing his duties in Caodaism. He said:

 “I need to master the mysterious key to spiritual liberation. Only then can I thoroughly understand the principles of Dao. Only then will I possess enough mystical power to navigate the boat of Caodaism to its destination.”

At midnight, saying goodbye, Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương ascended to the floor of the Heavenly Principles Secret Transmission, and started his intensive meditation. The entries in his meditation diary were detailed.([31])

THURSDAY, 24 SEPTEMBER 1942

The upper vehicle convent was inaugurated.

SATURDAY, 13 FEBRUARY 1943

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương issued his Declaration (excerpt):

“Because Caodaism was founded by God Himself, innumerable Deities, Saints, Immortals, and Buddhas have descended to this mortal world to help God spread the religion. Consequently, Caodaism will exist for seven hundred thousand years.

Those who do not follow Caodaism in their present lives, if they are reborn in this world in their next lives, and then in subsequent lives, they will ultimately enter Caodaism.([32])

1944

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương established the middle vehicle monastery. He established several Faith Transmitting Teams (Ban Truyền Tín 傳信班) consisting of dignitaries. These teams visited southern provinces to strengthen the faith of followers, encourage their self-cultivation, and initiate more people into Caodaism.

WEDNESDAY, 21 FEBRUARY 1945

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương issued his Declaration (excerpt):

This region [Bến Tre province, along with An Hóa and Chợ Lách districts] will experience favourable weather for crops. Its fields and gardens will become more luxuriant, and its atmosphere will often be fresh. As a result, its inhabitants will live at ease and healthy, free from fatal illnesses and safe from impending disasters.

To enjoy this happiness, one must simply obey the laws of the newly founded religion of Heaven. Observing veganism and doing good deeds is the most essential rule (...).” ([33])

SATURDAY, 19 MAY 1945

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương issued his Declaration (excerpt):

At this highly critical time, brethren should recall my instructions regarding the behaviour of Caodaists towards others. Especially, you should refrain from involvement in politics and warfare to avoid danger. Conversely, please diligently accumulate more merits and earnestly initiate more inhabitants of your parishes into Caodaism.

When helping your compatriots abandon wrongdoings and embrace righteousness, fostering benevolence, and accumulating virtue, you are truly contributing greatly to the nation by shaping citizens into good people. True patriotism is not defined by solely joining a political party.([34])

THURSDAY, 20 SEPTEMBER 1945

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương issued his Declaration (excerpt):

If brethren forget the teachings of our Master and do not remember my advice, you are putting yourselves in a dangerous place in this world, where struggles for power and interests prevail. It means that you are cornering Caodaism into a narrow space, going against the Heaven's will, breaking your vows, and violating the Heavenly law ...

In summary, do cultivate yourselves sincerely, and strive to become good examples of virtue, and attempt to guide sentient beings through the right path. Your such deeds will be very beneficial for both humans and our nation. Simultaneously, Your deeds are in harmony with the will of Heaven and please Heaven; thus, you can accumulate numerous blessings and help our nation evade impending disasters.” ([35])

MONDAY, 11 FEBRUARY 1946

The French army recaptured Bến Tre province. Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương left the Heavenly Principles Secret Transmission to meet with French officers to ensure the safety of followers and the Bến Tre Holy Assembly. Since his intensive meditation session had not yet ended, he communicated only by writing on paper.

AUGUST 1946

Apostle Nguyễn Ngọc Tương’s son, engineer Nguyễn Ngọc Bích was captured by colonial French soldiers.([36]) In order to observe the egoless impartiality of Caodaism, he refrained from utilising his influence to secure his son’s release, much like the situation in June 1949, when another of his sons, engineer Nguyễn Ngọc Nhựt, was also detained by colonial French soldiers

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương requested to have his Declarations translated into French, then printed in both Vietnamese and French before distributing them to followers. Each Declaration would be printed in around thirty thousand copies. Furthermore, he requested that his Declarations should be published in Vietnamese and French newspapers.

SATURDAY, 19 OCTOBER 1946

On behalf of Bishop Peter Martin Ngô Đình Thục (1897-1984), a delegation of officials visited the Bến Tre Holy Assembly and presented Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương with two issues: (a) How to end the Vietnamese-French conflict? (b) An aspiration for closer communication between Catholicism and Caodaism.

The Pope replied in writing:

 “As I am still in my intensive meditation session, I am not yet able to meet with you.

In order for France and Vietnam to understand each other better and avoid further conflicts, both sides must firmly acknowledge that everything has been determined by God, and then Buddhas, Immortals, Saints, and Deities carry out the will of Heaven.

Currently, to be certain about the existence of Heaven, Buddhas, Immortals, Saints, and Deities, one must acknowledge that Caodaism, which has existed in Vietnam since 1926 until now, is the religion founded by God. Additionally, let us examine the holy teachings bestowed by God and the sincere practice of Caodaism by its devoted followers.

Once understanding Caodaism thoroughly, one will realise that all of humanity are children of the same Heavenly Father, which means that we are all siblings, and together we uphold the common religion. Then, conflicts will disappear, and acts of love and harmony will prevail.

Since its early days, Caodaism has had the goodwill to communicate with the Five Branches of the Great Dao, which includes Catholicism. Naturally, as determined by the Heaven’s will, sooner or later, Catholicism will unite with Caodaism.

Now His Grace Bishop has expressed his wish to establish close contact, so the unity may be seen soon.

POPE LÝ [THÁI BẠCH]

Postscript: I would like to invite Your Excellencies to stay here for a few days to learn more about Caodaism.

Afterwards, Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương requested the Holy Assembly to send dignitaries to reciprocate a visit to Bishop Ngô Đình Thục.([37])

THURSDAY, 30 JANUARY 1947

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương issued his Declaration (excerpt):

“Sentient beings must endure immense suffering and face death as this world is about to be destroyed. Therefore, the religion of Heaven has been founded in the Third Era, granting the great amnesty. Sentient beings cannot enjoy this great amnesty unless they follow Caodaism, uphold it, and do good deeds.

The great amnesty is a very precious blessing from the religion of Heaven. Those who follow the religion of Heaven can be forgiven and exempted from sins in their past as well as present lives. As a result, their bodies and minds can be purified, which allows them to enjoy the air of purity. Consequently, they can evade the destruction in the final cycle of this world.” ([38])

FRIDAY, 07 MARCH 1947

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương issued his Declaration (excerpt):

In this very difficult period, you must strive to uphold Caodaism with greater fervour, strengthen your faith, and let no temptations force you away from Caodaism, leading you back to lives of chaos and suffering.

Having chosen to follow Caodaism, you must steadfastly adhere to the path you have chosen. Those who sincerely uphold the religion of Heaven can accumulate abundant blessings beneficial to sentient beings and our nation alike. A virtuous nation enjoys peace and prosperity for a long time. Conversely, an unvirtuous nation will sooner or later suffer from ceaseless disasters.” ([39])

MONDAY, 29 SEPTEMBER 1947

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương issued his Declaration (excerpt):

“I earnestly call upon all humans in southern Vietnam:

– You should give up all carnal desires, especially greed, hatred, and hostility.

You should firmly believe in Heaven, the Creator of humans and other creatures.

You should promptly follow the religion founded by God along with the Third Era’s great amnesty.

This is the one-of-a-kind path to eternal life. The Heaven’s Way has been founded to rescue sentient beings and bring them to the First Era of recreation. As the end of the world approaches, those who still hesitate will miss the rare opportunity to evade the destruction in the final cycle of this world.” ([40])

SATURDAY, 11 OCTOBER 1947

In the name of Pope Lý [Thái Bạch], the leader of Caodaism, His Holiness Nguyễn Ngọc Tương sent a letter to Emile Bollaert (1890-1978), the French High Commissioner of Indochina, who was appointed on 05 March 1947. Excerpts:

Truly established by God in 1926, Caodaism unites the Great Dao’s Five Branches, encompassing the Ways of Buddhas, Immortals, Saints, Deities, and Humans. Caodaism will urgently fulfil its official role, and through the earnest efforts of countless Divinities, it will spread across the Five Continents. Thanks to the great amnesty granted by Heaven in the Third Era, sentient beings will be saved from the destruction in the final cycle of this world.

Humans will only enjoy the great amnesty and save themselves from global destruction if they honestly follow the religion founded by God.”

For small and weak nations under protectorate, the Heaven's will decides that they must be liberated if they wish, so that they can act freely according to their aspirations (...).

In the last era of destruction, we should not waste time considering the affairs of worldly powers and fleeting interests. Our advantage lies in cooperating with each other based on faith in the religion newly founded by God, eliminating our selfishness that harms others, and sincerely fostering harmony through love and compassion. Through this swift transformation of our character, we will return to sacred blessings and enjoy the great amnesty of the Third Era, which can resolve conflicts amongst nations and restore peace and happiness.” ([41])

THURSDAY, 27 NOVEMBER 1947

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương issued his Declaration (excerpt):

As long as all peoples on earth recognise the existence of Heaven and Dao, fear karmic retribution, and respect righteousness as well as virtue over material wealth, then the struggle will cease, and global peace in a world of great harmony will be restored for a long time.” ([42])

THURSDAY, 25 MARCH 1948

The heading of the Declaration by His Holiness Pope Lý (i.e., Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương) obviously showed the name HỘI THÁNH BẾN TRE (the Bến Tre Assembly).([43])

THURSDAY, 02 JUNE 1949

Apostle Nguyễn Ngọc Tương’s son, engineer Nguyễn Ngọc Nhựt (1918-1952) was apprehended by colonial French soldiers. In order to maintain the egoless impartiality of Caodaism, the apostle refrained from utilising his influence to secure his son’s release, much like the situation in August 1947, when another of his sons, engineer Nguyễn Ngọc Bích, was also detained by colonial French soldiers.([44])

THURSDAY, 19 JANUARY 1950

From Bến Tre province, Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương sent a letter to Hà Nội holy house (still at 48 Hòa Mã street today), advising Thượng Priest Tô Văn Pho as follows:

“Dear brother Sáu,([45])

“I am almost finished with my meditation session. Those who truly cultivate themselves, have true loyalty to the Bến Tre Holy Assembly, diligently and enthusiastically do good deeds, improve virtue and accumulate meritorious service every day, wholeheartedly serve Caodaism, and steadfastly stand by me, will face more and more internal as well as external challenges until the day I finish my meditation session. The more challenges they face, the more merits they will accumulate, provided they do not complain or become discouraged.

So, always strive to keep your faith strong and firm; whoever tries to humiliate you, whoever insults or threatens you, whoever wants to harm you in any way, dont be angry or sad. Dont be shaken or frightened, either. Even if you suffer from illness, weakness, or bodily decay, no matter how much pain and affliction you endure, dont be sorrowful or discouraged. Dont neglect your religious duties, and dont harm your hidden virtue, either.

You should be certain that those who truly forget themselves to serve Caodaism are working for our Master; thus, they will always be supported by Divinities. No matter how dangerous the situation may seem, it will ultimately turn out for the good.” ([46])

AROUND THE SECOND HALF OF 1950

TO EARLY MONTHS OF 1951

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương requested most of the male and female dignitaries of the Bến Tre Holy Assembly to go upstairs to the Heavenly Principles Secret Transmission to instruct them. He received them in many sessions, earnestly advising them to strive to fulfil their duties and to cultivate themselves further in order to be fully virtuous.

In late 1950 and early 1951, Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương commanded the Bến Tre Holy Assembly to fulfil the following tasks: Completing personal records of dignitaries; printing enough religious publications for distribution; building graves for all deceased dignitaries; building outdoor water reservoirs for public use;([47]) buying white cloth for ceremonial purposes; and preparing a sum of money totalling forty to fifty thousand đồng (piasters). Additionally, he requested his family to renovate all the graves of his clan.([48])

SATURDAY, 09 JUNE 1951

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương instructed his two young male attendants:

I will be departing for an audience with our Great Merciful Father for seven days. You two should try to maintain serenity during this time. If you see me stop breathing for over seven days and I havent returned here, then you two will inform the Holy Assembly.” ([49])

TUESDAY, 12 JUNE 1951

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương immersed himself in meditation for days and nights.

SUNDAY, 17 JUNE 1951

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương ceased drinking water.

AT MIDNIGHT ON MONDAY, 18 AND

INTO THE SMALL HOURS OF TUESDAY, 19 JUNE 1951

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương passed away at midnight after nine years and eighty-one days of intensive meditation, as counted from the time he started his intensive meditation at midnight on 06 April and into the small hours of 07 April 1942.

WEDNESDAY, 20 JUNE 1951

Noticing that Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương had stopped breathing for a long time, the two young male attendants laid his body down.

FRIDAY, 22 JUNE 1951

Seeing that Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương’s hands and feet were cold, the two young male attendants became afraid. Although only four days had passed, they still left the Heavenly Principles Secret Transmission and went downstairs to inform the Bến Tre Holy Assembly.

SATURDAY, 23 JUNE 1951

The Bến Tre Holy Assembly sent for two public doctors and a private one. After examining the Pope’s body, the doctors confirmed that the Pope had passed away two days earlier. However, due to his strong spirit, his remains were still soft and had not yet decomposed. The Holy Assembly decided to leave his remains undisturbed for another twenty-four hours.

AT MIDNIGHT ON SUNDAY, 24 AND

INTO THE SMALL HOURS OF MONDAY, 25 JUNE 1951

At midnight, the Bến Tre Holy Assembly placed the remains of Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương in the coffin.

MONDAY, 25 JUNE 1951

At 3 p.m., the funeral ceremony started. The Bến Tre Holy Assembly, holy houses and private homes of Caodaists showed mourning flags. Each holy house set up an altar so that followers could pay homage to the deceased Pope from a distance. At 4 p.m., over a thousand attendees followed the coffin as it was moved from the Meditation House to the Holy Assembly, where it was positioned on the Papal throne in the main hall. The Holy Assembly issued Proclamation No. 1 regarding the funeral ceremony.([50])

THURSDAY, 28 JUNE 1951

Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương’s coffin was positioned on the high platform named the Heaven of Nine Layers (Cửu Trùng Thiên 九重天), constructed in an open large ground named the Great Harmony Ground (Đại Đồng Xã 大同社). One by one, offering ceremonies did not cease until Saturday, 07 July 1951. Totally, there were a hundred and thirty-six ceremonies offered by representaives of the government, other religions, other Caodai Holy Assemblies, and holy houses, etc. The funeral gathered over ten thousand mourners from northern, central, and southern Vietnam.

Every day, more than three thousand people visited the funeral. Over two thousand individuals shared their duties in the funeral.([51])

THURSDAY, 05 JULY 1951

The Bến Tre Holy Assembly issued Proclamation No. 2, containing three main points:

1. Clearly outlining the religious guidance of Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương.

2. Clearly reporting his liberation from the physical body.

3. Clearly defining the Holy Assembly’s religious policy in the present and future.

On the burial day, the Pope’s coffin was positioned on a hearse, adorned with white tuberoses (Polianthes tuberosa) arranged in the shape of the Dragon Horse 龍馬 carrying the Yellow River Chart 河圖. Over ten thousand Caodaists attended the ceremony. The hearse travelled throughout Bến Tre city, then returned to have the coffin positioned on the foundation of the stupa in front of the two towers (i.e., Hiệp Thiên Đài) of An Hội holy house.

Nhiêu Lộc, 16 March 2024

Huệ Khải



([1]) Subsequently, Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang referred to these two holy messages:

1/ The Supreme Being’s holy message bestowed during the evocation séance at Xuyên Mộc district in Bà Rịa province, on 16 July 1928. The mediums were Dharma Protector Phạm Công Tắc and Thượng Phẩm Cao Quỳnh Cư. The séance was witnessed by Messrs. Thượng Trung Nhựt, Thượng Tương Thanh, Thái Thơ Thanh, and Mrs. Principal Archbishop Hương Thanh.

2/ Spiritual Pope Lý Thái Bạch’s holy message bestowed during the evocation séance at the Holy See’s main temple, on 14 August 1931. The mediums were Dharma Protector Phạm Công Tắc and Culture Conservator Cao Quỳnh Diêu (1884-1958). The séance was witnessed by Messrs. Thượng Trung Nhựt, Thượng Tương Thanh, Ngọc Trang Thanh, Thái Thơ Thanh, and Mrs. Hương Thanh.

([2]) Châu Tri Chỉnh Đạo 1934-1936, pp. 27-30.

([3]) Châu Tri Chỉnh Đạo 1934-1936, pp. 32-33.

([4]) Breakdown of the 5,353 votes received: male and female dignitaries: 296 votes; male and female officials: 3,522 votes; delegates: 1,535 votes. Each delegate represented 100 followers; so, the number of votes from the delegates was equivalent to 153,500 votes. So, the 5,353 votes in the ballot box were equivalent to 157,318 votes. (Châu Tri Chỉnh Đạo 1934-1936, p. 33.)

([5]) Châu Tri Chỉnh Đạo 1934-1936, pp. 33-34.

([6]) Châu Tri Chỉnh Đạo 1934-1936, p. 34.

([7]) Châu Tri Chỉnh Đạo 1934-1936, pp. 37-38.

([8]) Châu Tri Chỉnh Đạo 1934-1936, p. 39.

([9]) Châu Tri Chỉnh Đạo 1934-1936, p. 44.

([10]) Bến Tre: F. Võ Văn Vân printing house, 1935, 19 pages.

See the illustration on page 169.

([11]) Châu Tri Chỉnh Đạo 1934-1936, p. 50.

([12]) Châu Tri Chỉnh Đạo 1934-1936, pp. 59-74.

([13]) The book was reprinted in 1954 (still 74 pages, 16x24cm) at Hòa Chánh printing house, at 16 Cống Quỳnh street, Saigon.

([14]) Minutes of Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang’s burial proceedings. The Holy Assembly formed the Funeral Organising Board on Friday, 24 July 1936.

([15]) Minutes of Thượng Legist-Censor Lê Bá Trang’s burial proceedings.

([16]) Perhaps the Tây Ninh Holy See implicitly denied all titles of the Bến Tre Holy Assembly’s dignitaries.

([17]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 50.

([18]) Huệ Khải, Cấm Đạo Cao Đài Ở Trung Kỳ (1928-1950) / Caodaism under Persecution in Central Vietnam (1928-1950). Hà Nội: Religion publishing house, 2012.

([19]) See the illustration on page 98.

([20]) Huệ Khải, Lịch Sử Thánh Thất Cao Đài Thủ Đô Hà Nội. Hà Nội: Religion publishing house, 2015.

([21]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, pp. 57-58.

([22]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 54.

([23]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 53.

([24]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 58.

([25]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 58.

([26]) For the gate of Trước Hoa Kỳ Thọ, see illustration, p. 94.

The Heavenly Principles Secret Transmission was the square room (3x3 metres) on the third floor where Pope Nguyễn Ngọc Tương engaged in intensive meditation. In 1935, it was temporarily constructed above the Heavenly Bestowal Hall. Below it was the restroom. Behind the Heavenly Principles Secret Transmission was the Meditation House.

Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 62.

([27]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 54.

([28]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 55.

([29]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 56.

([30]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 59.

([31]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, pp. 63-64.

([32]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 75.

([33]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 76.

([34]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 77.

([35]) Tiểu Sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 77.

([36]) Nguyễn Ngọc Bích was born in 1911 in An Hội village, Bảo Hựu canton (now Ward 5, Bến Tre city). He studied at the Polytech-nique in Paris and graduated as a civil engineer. Upon returning to Vietnam, he worked for the Water Resources Department (Sở Thủy Lợi) in Sóc Trăng province until the day of the Japanese coup d’état against the French. After the nationwide resistance day (19 December 1946), he participated in the resistance war. When the French army attacked Sóc Trăng province, he was captured on 25 August 1946. In 1948, he was forcibly sent to France. In Paris, he established Minh Tân publishing house. He became a doctor specialising in cancer. Passing away in 1966 in Thủ Đức district due to cancer, he was buried in Bến Tre province, near his brother Nguyễn Ngọc Nhựt.

([37]) Tiểu sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, pp. 71-72.

([38]) Tiểu sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, pp. 75-76.

([39]) Tiểu sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 77.

([40]) Tiểu sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 76.

([41]) Tiểu sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, pp. 72-73.

([42]) Tiểu sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 76.

([43]) See the illutration on p. 83.

([44]) Born on 15 September 1918, in An Hội village (now Ward 5, Bến Tre city), Nguyễn Ngọc Nhựt studied in France, and graduated as an engineer. He worked as a technical specialist for French commercial enterprises for several years. His spouse was a French engineer’s daughter.

In 1946, he attempted to return to Vietnam and participated in the resistance war. On 02 June 1949, during an attack by colonial French soldiers in Đồng Tháp Mười, he was captured in Cái Bèo (in Sa Đéc province, now renamed Đồng Tháp province).

After numerous failed attempts to seduce him into submission, the French soldiers brutally tortured him, injecting him with drugs to induce nervous disorders. Ultimately, he was sent to the mental hospital of Biên Hòa, where he was detained without treatment. It was there that he sacrificed his life on 16 May 1952.

The Government of the Democratic Republic of Vietnam (North Vietnam) posthumously awarded him the title of martyr and the First Class Order of Resistance.

([45]) Instead of the birth name Tô Văn Pho, “brother Sáu” (em Sáu) is an affectionate way to address him.

([46]) Huệ Khải, Lược Sử Thánh Thất Cao Đài Thủ Đô Hà Nội. Hà Nội: Religion publishing house, 2015, pp. 65-66.

([47]) See the illustration on page194.

([48]) Tiểu sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 81.

([49]) Tiểu sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 82.

([50]) Tiểu sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, pp. 85-86.

([51]) Tiểu sử Đức Giáo Tông Nguyễn Ngọc Tương, p. 87.